Friday, December 16, 2011

Macro Blog 11 - Drug Testing for Welfare

With a weakening economy, more and more people are resorting to government programs as a way to make ends meet. It is understandable for citizens to support one another in times of financial crisis; however there has been much concern with how the money from tax payers is used. As stereotypical as it is, many hard working tax payers feel the economy can re-flourish if the unemployed simply abandoned their drugs and stop being lazy. Though these characteristics do not apply to all members of poverty, it is not reassuring to tax payers if their money is going to the members of poverty that are addicted to drugs and lazy. Therefore, the controversial idea of drug testing welfare recipients has been suggested. This plan helps reassure tax payers that their money is going to people who need it; not to those who will spend it all on drugs. What makes this idea controversial, however, is that some argue that it is an unreasonable search and seizure and therefore a violation to the rights of the American citizen. When deciding if drug testing should be administered for welfare recipients, several components should be considered, including financing, the outcome of a tax payer's money, and the violation of constitutional protection from unreasonable search and seizure.

While the country is already in debt, there doesn't appear to be any sense in spending money to drug test the unemployed. Although it does increase government spending, what must also be considered is the amount of money saved due to unpaid benefits. According to the article States Adding Drug Test as Hurdle for Welfare, "Only 16 out of 64,000 answered yes; 931 did not submit the form. The state estimated the savings on benefits had totaled $116,000" (Sulzberger). This amount of saving is caused by a mere thousand unpaid benefits and has much potential to benefit the country. According to Sulzberger, drug tests "cost up to $40." This means that the price for a drug test can be found for a reasonable price the unemployed can pay themselves. Florida has thought of this, and Sulzberger writes, "people receiving cash assistance through welfare have had to pay for their own drug tests since July, and enrollment has shrunk to its lowest levels since the start of the recession." With people paying for their own drug testing and money spent on unemployment benefits decreasing, drug testing welfare recipients appears to be beneficial.

The hard working American citizen only hopes that their hard-earned money is spent to support the country and not gone to waste. A common reason for unwise spending is the drugs purchased with unemployment benefits. How can the government know whether or not the money they provide people in need goes to drugs? Drug testing is a way of reassurance to prevent spending on drugs. And although not all impoverished people are drug users, according to the article Unemployment Drug Tests: Republicans' Unprecedented Pursuit Of Drug Testing The Jobless, "unemployed people were more than twice as likely to use drugs than people with full-time jobs" (Delaney). This supports the fear of tax money likely being spent on drugs. Many working citizens have a similar fear of how their money is spent, and as Sulzberger says, "'Working people today work very hard to make ends meet, and it just doesn’t seem fair to them that their tax dollars go to support illegal things.'" Therefore, if drug testing for welfare recipients was enforced, the money spent would more likely support families in need of financial aid rather than drug addicts.

No comments:

Post a Comment